The social discount rate andrew caplin and john leahy. At an intuitive level, the discount rate used should be consistent with both the riskiness and the type of cash. In the context of climate change policymaking, they are considered very important for working out how much todays society should invest in trying to limit the impacts of climate change in the future. Discount rate sdr an estimate of how society values consumption at different points in time.
In economics, time preference or time discounting, delay discounting, temporal discounting, longterm orientation is the current relative valuation placed on receiving a good at an earlier date compared with receiving it at a later date. Social discount rates are important in calculating the benefits and costs of limiting future climate change, because carbon dioxide has a very long residence time in the atmosphere, which means that we must value the impacts of todays emissions centuries into the future. Discount rates for environmental benefits occurring in the. This paper presents estimates of the social discount rates for nine latin american countries. In finance, the term is used to describe the amount of cash currency that is generated or consumed in a given time period. Errors in estimating the discount rate or mismatching cash. Social discount rate in theory there is a body of theoretical literature on the choice of sdr. The appropriate selection of a social discount rate is crucial for costbenefit analysis, and has important implications for resource allocations. As such it is one of the most critical inputs needed for costbenefit analysis. Public and private sector discount rates in publicprivate partnerships paul a grout cmpo, university of bristol september 2002 abstract whether public sector projects should be discounted at a lower rate than private sector projects is a highly contentious issue and one that has spawned an enormous literature. In this regard, estimates in the 56 percent would be more appropriate. Using the opportunity cost of capital would be better described as a method of obtaining an sdr than as.
The social rate of time preference and the social discount. We show that application of this revealed preference criterion rests on faith, not on logic. Social discount rate sdr is the discount rate used in computing the value of funds spent on social projects. Pdf 1mb cited by the social discount rate measures the rate at which a society would be willing to trade present for future consumption. Public and private sector discount rates in publicprivate. The annual rate of decrease of these factors is the social discount rate sdr. A revision 77 the exponential discounting model and it is proposed a 5% european so cial dis count rate as a standard benchmark for co. Choosing an appropriate social discount rate is crucial for costbene t analysis, and has important implications for resource allocations. If we take the rate that the average saver uses to discount future consumption as our measure of the social rate of time preference, then the real rate of return on longterm government debt may provide a fair approximation. Applying a 3 percent social discount rate to future natural gas costs lower than the current discount rate that is based on the utilitys cost of capital would raise, and thus more accurately reflect, the apparent costs of natural gas. What discount rate should be applied to social investments. The article concludes that the appropriate social discount rate for australia, for all sectors and states and territories, is approximately 6.
The 3 percent discount rate required in circular a4 was based on the real rate of return on longterm government debt. We distinguish between a socialwelfareequivalent discount rate appropriate for determining whether a given policy would augment social welfare according to a postulated social welfare function and a financeequivalent discount rate suitable for determining whether the policy would offer a potential pareto improvement. Obviously, adopting a much higher discount rate as recommended by nordhaus. Gives the value of one unit in the future generally in one year in present value terms discount rate r. The social discount rate for provincial government investment projects peter s. Discounting the economics of climate change c 175 economic solution concept. The annual rate of decrease of these factors is the social discount rate. Each of the methods described above uses a discount factor to translate values across time, so. The social discount rate for provincial government.
This gives a social rate of time preference stp that is appropriate for discounting costs and benefits measured in consumption units. It is justified only if preferences over all choices, including past choices, are time invariant. The treasury guidelines on cost benefit analysis, henceforth the green book, takes as the social discount rate sdr an estimate of how society values consumption at different points in time. This method of discounting allows analysts to compare alternative social projects to a baseline scenario, one in which resources are left in private hands instead of being commandeered for public purposes.
Social risk premium amount required to compensate capital owners for potential differences between expected and actual returns. Cash flow cash flow cf is the increase or decrease in the amount of money a business, institution, or individual has. This gives a social rate of time preference stp that is appropriate for discounting costs and benefits. The green book recommends that costs and benefits occurring in the first 30 years of a programme, project or policy be discounted at an annual rate of 3. A positive social discount rate for health effects is therefore implied if the consumption value of health is decreasing. It is standard to use the market interest rate, thereby respecting private preferences. Figures 105 and 106 summarize the texts recommendations concerning the social discount rate. However, the consumption value of health is likely to be increasing. The social discount rate is a reflection of a societys relative valuation on todays wellbeing versus wellbeing in the future. The social discount rate is the interest rate used in costbenefit analyses of infrastructure and other public projects. Policymakers should use a modified version of what is known as the weighted average approach to discounting. Discount rates critical ingredient in discounted cash. Social discounting of large dams with climate change.
The table shows that this hesitation is not innocuous. The choice of discount rate for climate change policy. Discount rate used by transport agencies in selected oecd countries jurisdiction method discount rate real france risk. Choosing the appropriate social discount rate seems still central in the economic analysis. January 2004 abstract what discount rate should be applied to social investments. Discount rates in energy system analysis discussion paper. Determining this rate is not always easy and can be the subject of discrepancies in the true net benefit to certain projects, plans and policies. Theory maintains that, if there was a single capital market that was perfectly competitive, there will be one interest rate that prevails, and this one interest rate would equate marginal time preference of savers with the marginal productivity of capital. Boardman and others published the social discount rate in canada find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Figure 1 shows the range of social discount rates resulting from the combination of different estimates of these parameters. Pdf on the use of discount rates in intergenerational cost.
As a result, social planners using a high discount rate will have a tendency to favor projects with shortrun benefits. As seen from the discussion of the stern report on climate change see stern, 2007, and nordhaus, 2007, differences in the social discount rate can have substantial implications for evaluating the costs and benefits of public projects. The social discount rate journal of political economy. The lowest social rate of return on projects accepted in the past therefore indicates the upper limit of the social discount rate and if investment is at optimal level, it should equal the social discount rate.
There is a body of theoretical literature on the choice of sdr. There is no absolute distinction that separates high and low time preference, only comparisons with others either individually or in aggregate. Recently, a number of authors, including burgess and zerbe, have recommended the use of a real social discount rate sdr in the range of 68% in benefitcost analysis bca of public projects. Discounting future fuel costs at a social discount rate. They derive this rate based on the social opportunity cost of capital soc method. Third, a new chapter on benefit valuation by sector has been added, which details the method for valuing project benefits in major sectors of adb operations. We show that application of this revealed preference criterion rests on faith, not logic. Discount rate definition, types and examples, issues.
It should be noted that the net present value and net future value can be expressed relative to one another. He argues in favour of a social rate of return that is not only lower than the private rate of return, but that is expected. As indicated by these two figures, the discount rate, as well as upper and lower bounds for sensitivity tests, that. There is wide diversity in social discount rates, with developed. The appropriate metric for the alternative project rate of return is average market return allowing for non. Social discount rates sdrs are used to put a present value on costs and benefits that will occur at a later date. Gives the rate at which future value is discounted it holds r d 1. Three arguments in favour of a negative social discount rate.
Problems arise when aggregating individual ramsey discount rate functions into a social discount rate function that would serve as a basis for an sdr. To the extent that the region improves on its past performance, which admittedly has been quite dismal and therefore may bias the results, the social discount rate to be used in the evaluation of future projects would increase. Spiro 1 this is a prepublication version of a chapter that was published in the book discount rates for the evaluation of public private partnerships d. The second method estimates the social rate of time preference by examining the real rate of return on the almost riskless obligations of the u. One reason for this is that the marginal utility of consumption is likely to diminish faster than the marginal utility of health. Pdf the social discount rate in canada researchgate.
Discount rate x year is a concave function of a discount rate. For intragenerational proj ects defined as those with up to a 50 year horizon, it is standard practice to use weights that decline at a constant rate. Lind et al1982, among others, suggest that the discount rate consists of two components. Determinants of social discount rate, general case the economics of climate change c 175 the resulting equation r. A social discount rate reflects a societys relative valuation on todays wellbeing versus wellbeing in the future.
67 654 202 1453 909 1183 783 1456 1256 29 862 624 855 1434 56 198 736 1367 1434 1349 221 38 1117 1151 479 1180 1178 544 513 809 86 493 124 182 1517 533 1518 865 1306 488 30 377 1209 368 1453 1208 295 122 1046